Tuesday, November 11, 2008

Beyonce as Wonder Woman?

There are reports floating around that singer/actress/entrepreneur Beyonce is in talks to play Wonder Woman in the long-anticipated film adaptation of the beloved comic book and '70s television show starring Lynda Carter.

I like Beyonce. She makes some good music, and she surprised me by giving a fairly weighty performance in Dreamgirls. But to me, she is still an average actress, and playing such a high-profile role in a film for an actress with a handful of film credits is a big risk.

Physically, Beyonce has the amazon-like figure that Wonder Woman requires, but she doesn't have the grace, innocence, great comic timing or - dare I say it? - sexiness that Lynda Carter brought to the role in the 1970s. Now, Lynda Carter will never be accused of being a great actress, but there is no denying it: she was great as Diana/Wonder Woman, and made the show worth watching, even in the awful second season when WW switched from the '40s to the present-day, disco-bathed '70s.

As much as Beyonce looks the part of Wonder Woman, she doesn't embody her. I think it would be a good idea to go with an unknown actor, like they did with Daniel Craig for Casino Royale. Although he had a fair share of acting credits, most movie audiences were unfamiliar with Craig, and that factor helped make Casino Royale to become a monster hit.

Perhaps one of the reasons I am not too enthusiastic about Beyonce playing Wonder Woman is because Beyonce is overexposed. She's on the radio, on music video channels, hair commercials, make-up commercials, tabloids, awards shows, and it goes on and on. Beyonce has become a corporation; it's much more difficult to buy her as an Amazon goddess/warrior.

Who knows who will play Wonder Woman in a WW feature film, if that ever happens. But if it should be Beyonce, I remain skeptical.

But then again, I was skeptical when Daniel Craig was cast as James Bond. And we all know how that turned out...

2 comments:

Avenue Road said...

Just say no to Ms. B as Wonder Woman. Even Whitney on Drugs couldn't agree to that. LOL

TPC said...

haha true

Did you know that Beyonce is playing Etta James in an upcoming music docudrama about Chess Records? Crazy!